On following recipes….

I’ve been in Mexico for five days, exploring Puebla with the Mexican Tourism Board. You know, Puebla, the home of mole poblano. And other delicious treats like chulupas, chilaquiles, sopa poblana, cemitas and cremitas (don’t worry you’ll find out more soon!). In any case, it’s quite fitting that this month’s Kitchen Bootcamp challenge was salads because after four days being well fed and looked after, it’s salads I definitely need to be eating for the next little while.

This month, I decided to use (and follow) a recipe from the New Best Recipe. Yes, follow a recipe. For salad. I realized when I started leafing through the chapter for this challenge (Chapter 3), that, whilst I make salads quite often, I rarely follow a recipe per se. Especially for dressings. Shocking I know but I always figure if I taste as I go, you can’t go wrong.  Well this challenge was eye opening for me because I made this salad (Wilted Spinach Salad with Goat Cheese, Olives and Lemon Vinaigrette, p 88) twice – once kinda sorta following the recipe and the second time, absolutely following the recipe to the word. Guess what? When I winged it, it was tasty but when I followed the recipe it was so much better – a much more refined, subtle taste. A lesson for me, for sure – especially when it comes to dressings, I probably need to make many more of them to understand the quantities and ratios a bit more clearly.

To be fair to me, the first time I was making this, it was part of a pretty full-on meal – seaweed sablés for hors d’oeuvres, coq au vin for mains and French strawberry cake for dessert. Somewhere in between all that, the salad got lost. I measured out the quantities for the dressing but stopped following the directions after I had prepared that.  Instead of drizzling the warm dressing over the spinach (hence the “wilted”) and sprinkling the goat cheese on top just before serving, I tossed the spinach in the warm dressing and mixed in the goat cheese in the pan. And left it just a little too long. It was a bit TOO wilted and the goat cheese was very rich as it was practically melted too.  Our guests liked it but both Neil and I felt it was overly rich and the goat cheese (which I realize I didn’t measure properly) was little overpowering.

Can you see a little friend climbing up the fork?

The next day I made it again (never one to be beaten by a salad recipe!) and followed the directions to a T. Oh, I might have added a little lemon zest which the recipe did not call for but apart from that I stuck to the New Best Recipe way pretty closely.  I mean, they DO test their recipes so many times why would I think I know better than them?

Ladybird decided the salad was pretty tasty too!

This is a simple salad with just a few ingredients – spinach, olives, goat cheese for the salad proper and shallots, garlic, oil and lemon juice for the dressing.  But proof that simple ingredients (prepared correctly), can produce wonderfully complex flavours.

Kitchen Bootcamp is working through The New Best Recipe (from the editors of Cook’s Illustrated). Want to join us working through this fabulous book? Check out the Kitchen Bootcamp page here and buy The New Best Recipe on Amazon.ca or Amazon.com.


23 thoughts on “On following recipes….”

  1. First try was acceptable…but done properly, it was MUCH better.

    For thsoe who haven’t seen it, this cookbook is quite fun – highly recommended.

  2. What a lovely salad. We are big salad eaters at our house. I’m a recipe follower and my husband is not. I measure, he doesn’t. We share the kitchen & cooking and it’s interesting to see how some recipes turn out.

    Love the shot of the ladybug on the fork.

  3. It seems like the simplest recipes (the ones that I don’t think I need to pay attention to) are the ones that trip me up the most…
    Lovely salad.

  4. Lucky you to be in Mexico…I am sure you are having a ball and eating so well! I can understand your need to do salads afterwards…I totally felt that way after a week of overindulgence in India recently, which led to a 3-day juice cleanse upon return to Bkk! Your salad is gorgeous…I tend to follow the recipes for dressing often, as this is one area I’m not so comfortable with.

  5. Your ‘experiment’s’ results are very interesting because I so often only use a recipe for a springboard, I guess that if you’ve got the same ingredients as indicated then that really should be the best way of doing things and the best ratios. Thought provoking. 🙂

  6. Envious of your travels in Mexico! I still haven’t been there but am dying to go! I eat a salad pretty much every day and never tried the wilted spinach technique. Looks flavorful and refreshing! I also love your photo with the lady bug on the fork – gorgeous!

  7. Chilaquiles!! I love them, with green sauce more than red. Oh, and I’ve already detailed my inability/unwillingness to follow recipes, so I absolutely need to take this post to heart.

  8. we make a lot of wilted salads in the summer, both spinach and lettuce, and i have been looking for a variation on my standard bacon/sugar/vinegar dressing – i think i’ll try the warm lemon vinaigrette instead – thanks!


Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.